14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (2024)

Wait—don't throw out those overripe tomatoes! Instead, transform them using one of these delicious recipes. Overripe tomatoes are perfect for sauces and soups as their softer texture is easily masked when blended with other flavors. You could also roast them and use it as a side dish. Recipes like Easy Tomato Gazpacho and No-Peel Slow-Cooker Marinara Sauce are flavorful, bright and make the most out of those still-great tomatoes.

01of 14

Slow-Roasted Tomatoes

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (1)

Slowly cooking summer-ripe tomatoes in a low oven makes them candy-sweet. Turn to this recipe to preserve the summer bounty from your garden or farmers' market; it freezes well for up to 6 months. Tuck these tasty bites into sandwiches; stir them into risotto; or chop them and mix with Kalamata olives, olive oil and fresh herbs to scoop up with pita chips. Source: EatingWell Magazine, September 2020

02of 14

Easy Tomato Gazpacho

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (2)

Many gazpacho recipes are thickened with bread, but this one uses just vegetables, making it a gluten-free refresher for a hot summer day. The key to any flavorful gazpacho is giving it time to rest. The flavors meld and become cohesive when the soup is allowed to sit a bit before serving. Source: EatingWell.com, July 2018

03of 14

Roasted Tomato Soup and Grilled Cheese Sandwiches

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (3)

The classic lunch of tomato soup with a grilled cheese sandwich gets an upgrade with roasted tomatoes and fresh herbs in the soup, and a warm grilled sandwich with two kinds of cheese. Source: Diabetic Living Magazine

No-Peel Slow-Cooker Marinara Sauce

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (4)

Store-bought pasta sauce just can't compare to homemade marinara--and the slow cooker makes marinara from scratch much easier. This fresh tomato recipe was developed to preserve the summer bounty from your garden or farmers' market; it freezes well for up to 6 months so you can pull out pasta or pizza sauce anytime. Keeping the skins on makes it even easier, plus they contain pectin, which helps thicken the sauce. Source: EatingWell Magazine, September 2020

05of 14

Lasagna with Slow-Roasted Tomato Sauce

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (5)

Slow-roasting the tomatoes gives the tomato sauce for this lasagna recipe an intense depth of flavor--which is then enhanced by the umami in onions, Parmesan and spinach. The lasagna noodles are layered into the lasagna uncooked; the moisture from the fresh spinach cooks them perfectly as the lasagna bakes in the oven. Source: EatingWell Magazine, May/June 2012

06of 14

Spaghetti Squash with Roasted Tomatoes, Beans & Almond Pesto

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (6)

Looking at a tangle of spaghetti squash tricks your brain into thinking you're about to eat a serving of eggy noodles, when in fact, you get a nice calorie and carb savings in this healthy recipe. Giving tomatoes a stint in a hot oven makes them candy-sweet. Source: EatingWell Magazine, January/February 2017

07of 14

Pasta with Fresh Tomato Sauce

View Recipe

To avoid a watery sauce, choose tomatoes that are fleshy and have few seeds. Romas (aka plum tomatoes) fit the bill, but there are plenty of heirlooms with a similar flesh-to-seed ratio. The addition of cherry tomatoes brings a burst of sweetness to the dish. Source: EatingWell Magazine, July / August 2020

08of 14

Smoky and Spicy Tomato Pasta Sauce

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (8)

This tomato sauce is anything but ordinary, with a combination of smoked paprika and sweet red peppers. Source: Diabetic Living Magazine

09of 14

Moroccan Chicken & Tomato Stew

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (9)

This Moroccan chicken stew is inspired by a traditional tagine, a dish which takes its name from the pottery vessel it's made in (a skillet works here). Serve with a side of roasted vegetables and whole-wheat couscous, if desired. Source: Diabetic Living Magazine, Spring 2020

10of 14

Roasted Salmon & Tomatoes with Garlic & Olives

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (10)

Keep the mess to minimum with this easy sheet-pan dinner. Cherry tomato halves roast alongside salmon fillets and make a delicious topping combined with olives, garlic and thyme in this easy fuss-free dinner. Source: EatingWell.com, March 2020

11of 14

Pressure-Cooker Tomato Sauce

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (11)

A multicooker is the perfect vessel for making homemade tomato sauce. You can sauté to develop flavor with the aromatic ingredients, then cook everything under pressure to infuse the tomatoes with garlic, onion, oregano and a splash of red wine. If the tomatoes are sweet on their own, you may not need the optional teaspoon of sugar. Taste before adding. Source: EatingWell.com, July 2018

12of 14

Mediterranean Cabbage Soup

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (12)

This vegan soup recipe is surprisingly easy to make. The flavorful broth is spiked with garlic, tomatoes and a hint of coriander. Just slice and dice your cabbage and fennel and you'll be enjoying this quick healthy soup in no time. Source: EatingWell.com, January 2020

13of 14

Roasted Cherry Tomato & Sage Sauce

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (13)

There are endless ways to use this sage-flecked roasted cherry tomato sauce recipe: serve with baked fish, spread it on a panini or simply toss it with whole-wheat pasta for an instant, quick and flavorful dinner. Source: EatingWell Magazine, May/June 2013

14of 14

White Bean Soup with Tomato & Shrimp

View Recipe

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (14)

With capers and olives, this heart-healthy soup draws inspiration from Italian puttanesca sauce. Serve with crusty whole-grain bread to soak up the broth. Source: EatingWell Magazine, January/February 2020

14 Recipes for Overripe Tomatoes (2024)

FAQs

What can I do with mature tomatoes? ›

Wait—don't throw out those overripe tomatoes! Instead, transform them using one of these delicious recipes. Overripe tomatoes are perfect for sauces and soups as their softer texture is easily masked when blended with other flavors. You could also roast them and use it as a side dish.

Is it OK to use overripe tomatoes? ›

But although they're not great for eating raw, tomatoes that have gone a little beyond their ideal deadline are still packed with flavour, health benefits and juicy goodness. In fact, the underrated overripe tomato tends to be even sweeter and juicier than its unripe counterpart.

Can you freeze whole ripe tomatoes? ›

Tomatoes may be frozen raw or cooked, whole, sliced, chopped, or puréed. Tomatoes do not need to be blanched before freezing. Frozen tomatoes are best used in cooked foods such as soups, sauces and stews as they become mushy when they're thawed.

How to make tomato paste out of tomatoes? ›

Bring tomatoes to a boil, then lower your heat and simmer for about 15 minutes, or until the tomatoes are soft. Place simmered tomatoes into a blender and blend at high speed until fully pureed (including the skins and any seeds that didn't get squeeze out).

What is tomato blight? ›

Tomato blight (also known as late blight) is a disease caused by a fungus-like (Oomycete) organism that spreads rapidly through the foliage and fruit of tomatoes in warm, wet weather, causing collapse and decay. It can be a very serious disease on outdoor tomatoes.

Are old tomatoes good for soil? ›

Tomatoes are a valuable addition to your compost bin, and can be added whether they are fresh, cooked or moldy! However, there is definitely a 'right' way to add them. Follow the steps below and you'll be a tomato-composting guru in no time at all!

Do tomatoes last longer in the fridge or on the counter? ›

Ripe Tomatoes

And unless you're eating them immediately, ripe, locally grown tomatoes will also last longer in the fridge; eat within a few days. Store ripe tomatoes in your fridge stress-free and enjoy them within a couple days of purchasing.

How do you know if tomatoes are too old? ›

Bad tomatoes also tend to leak fluid. If you pick up a tomato and notice that there is fluid underneath it, then it has gone bad. Feel – if a tomato is soft or mushy when given a light squeeze, it has gone bad. Smell – if you find that a tomato is producing a bitter or putrid smell, then it has gone bad.

Can I eat week old tomatoes? ›

How long do fresh tomatoes last? Fresh tomatoes will last from two to five days on the counter at room temperature. A refrigerated ripe tomato can last up to two weeks. Cut tomatoes only last in a cool fridge for a day or two.

When should you throw away tomatoes? ›

Tomatoes should have taught, blemish-free skin. If there's a bruised spot or two, it's OK to cut around them and enjoy the rest of the tomato (maybe turn it into a nice tomato sauce), but if the entire fruit is pocked with spots, it's best to move on.

What to do with wrinkled tomatoes? ›

You can eat them straight out of the skillet as I do, but there are more civilized choices: Toss the tomatoes with pasta, mash them a little and pile them on toast, fold them into scrambled eggs, or serve them over grilled chicken, steak, or fish. So go ahead, buy a few more pints at the farmers market while you can.

Can you cut mold off a tomato and still eat it? ›

The USDA recommends cutting off at least one inch around and below the mold spot on the food. When asked about soft fruits and vegetables that go moldy such as cucumbers, peaches and tomatoes, she said these were best avoided.

Will tomato plants grow back if you cut them? ›

If the plant is healthy and the branch was cut during the growing season (typically spring and summer), it is more likely that the plant will be able to regrow from the cut branch. In this case, the plant will form new shoots and leaves at the site of the cut, and it may even produce new fruit.

How do you can tomatoes for long term storage? ›

Here's how to do it:
  1. Wash and peel the tomatoes; halve, if desired.
  2. Fill the jars, pressing to fill spaces with juice.
  3. Add bottled lemon juice and salt (1 Tbsp. lemon juice and ¼ to ½ tsp. salt for pints; add 2 Tbsp. lemon juice and ½ to 1 tsp. ...
  4. In a boiling-water canner, process pints and quarts for 85 minutes.
Aug 8, 2023

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duane Harber

Last Updated:

Views: 5871

Rating: 4 / 5 (51 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duane Harber

Birthday: 1999-10-17

Address: Apt. 404 9899 Magnolia Roads, Port Royceville, ID 78186

Phone: +186911129794335

Job: Human Hospitality Planner

Hobby: Listening to music, Orienteering, Knapping, Dance, Mountain biking, Fishing, Pottery

Introduction: My name is Duane Harber, I am a modern, clever, handsome, fair, agreeable, inexpensive, beautiful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.